The debate about the greatest guitar solos of all time is a passionate one amongst music aficionados. Recently, the conversation with friends Alex and Sue led to a definitive suggestion: Prince’s electrifying live rendition of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps.” This wasn’t just any performance; it was a star-studded event featuring George Harrison’s son Dhani, ELO’s Jeff Lynne, Tom Petty, Steve Winwood, and other musical giants. This memorable performance ignited a quest to uncover the very best versions of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” ever recorded.
“While My Guitar Gently Weeps” was originally penned by George Harrison for The Beatles’ iconic “White Album.” Interestingly, the song initially didn’t resonate strongly with the other Beatles. During its recording at EMI Studios in London in 1968, Harrison sought the musical expertise of his friend Eric Clapton, who contributed the now-famous guitar solo, albeit uncredited at the time.
Over time, the song has achieved classic status. Rolling Stone magazine recognized its brilliance by ranking “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” at number 10 on their list of The Beatles’ 100 Greatest Songs and further lauded it at number 7 on the 100 Greatest Guitar Songs of All Time. Its enduring appeal is evident in the numerous covers spanning diverse genres, with guitarists particularly drawn to its expressive solo.
Driven by curiosity, we embarked on a comprehensive listening journey through every available version of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” on Apple Music to curate a definitive top five. This ranking is based on a critical evaluation of each version’s arrangement, its originality in interpreting the classic, the vocal performance, and, crucially, the impact and artistry of the guitar solo.
5) George Harrison (Live in Japan, 1992)
This live rendition from George Harrison’s 1992 tour in Japan, featuring Eric Clapton and his band, holds a special place due to Clapton’s direct involvement. While this version might not drastically reimagine the song’s arrangement, its core strength lies in Clapton revisiting and performing his original, uncredited solo from the “White Album.” There’s a historical resonance in hearing Clapton, the original voice behind the studio solo, recreate it live alongside Harrison. The familiarity of the arrangement allows Clapton’s guitar work to take center stage, offering a nostalgic nod to the song’s studio origins.
| Arrangement | Familiar |
|---|---|
| Originality | Minimal |
| Solo | Clapton’s Classic Rendition |
| Vocals | Harrison’s Solid Performance |
Alt text: George Harrison performing live in Japan in 1992, Eric Clapton’s band visible in the background, capturing a historic musical collaboration.
Listen on Apple Music and Spotify.
4) Peter Frampton (Album “Now”, 2003)
Peter Frampton, celebrated for his work with Humble Pie and his successful solo career, recorded “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” for his 2003 album “Now.” Frampton’s version stays relatively close to the well-known structure of the song. However, what elevates this rendition is his exceptional guitar solo. Frampton injects his signature soaring, melodic style into the solo, creating a performance that many guitar enthusiasts find surpasses even Harrison’s and Clapton’s takes in terms of sheer emotive guitar playing. His solo is a masterclass in phrasing and tone, making it a standout moment. For those seeking an even more dynamic experience, an incredible live version is also available, showcasing Frampton’s improvisational skills further.
| Arrangement | Classic Interpretation |
|---|---|
| Originality | Moderate |
| Solo | Soaring and Melodic Frampton Solo |
| Vocals | Strong Frampton Vocals |
Alt text: Peter Frampton passionately playing guitar during a live concert, bathed in stage lighting, highlighting his expressive performance style.
Listen on Apple Music and Spotify.
3) The Beatles (The White Album, 1968)
No list of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” renditions would be complete without acknowledging The Beatles’ original recording from their self-titled “White Album.” This version is historically significant as the genesis of the song, featuring George Harrison’s songwriting and Eric Clapton’s uncredited guitar overdub. While the arrangement is now considered classic and foundational, its originality is undeniable. Clapton’s solo, even within the context of a Beatles song, is remarkably poignant and tasteful, perfectly complementing the song’s melancholic mood. It’s a benchmark recording, setting the standard against which all subsequent versions are often measured.
| Arrangement | Original Beatles Arrangement |
|---|---|
| Originality | Groundbreaking |
| Solo | Clapton’s Iconic Original Solo |
| Vocals | Harrison’s Distinctive Vocals |
Alt text: The iconic stark white cover of The Beatles’ White Album, symbolizing the original recording of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” with Eric Clapton’s legendary solo.
Listen on Apple Music and Spotify.
2) Tom Petty, Jeff Lynne, Steve Winwood, Dhani Harrison, and Prince (Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, 2004)
This performance, a tribute to George Harrison upon his induction into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2004, assembled an extraordinary lineup: Dhani Harrison, Jeff Lynne, Tom Petty, and Steve Winwood. Each contributed to a heartfelt rendition of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps.” However, it was Prince who unequivocally stole the show. His guitar solo was nothing short of astonishing, an explosive display of virtuosity and emotion that captivated everyone present and those who have watched the recording since. Prince’s interpretation wasn’t just about technical skill; it was a deeply expressive and transformative moment, widely regarded as one of the most electrifying live guitar performances ever. This version is particularly celebrated for showcasing Prince’s unique genius and his ability to elevate a classic song to new heights. The sheer unexpected brilliance of Prince’s solo makes this performance unforgettable and places it near the very top.
| Arrangement | Collaborative Tribute Arrangement |
|---|---|
| Originality | Unique Live Event |
| Solo | Prince’s Show-Stopping Solo |
| Vocals | Shared Vocals by Ensemble |
Alt text: Prince delivering a mind-blowing guitar solo at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame tribute to George Harrison, capturing his legendary musical prowess.
Watch on YouTube.
1) Carlos Santana (with India.Arie and Yo-Yo Ma, Album “Guitar Heaven”, 2010)
Taking the top spot is Carlos Santana’s 2010 rendition from his album “Guitar Heaven…The Greatest Guitar Classics of All Time.” Santana’s version distinguishes itself through its unique and inspired arrangement, incorporating the soulful vocals of India.Arie and the sublime cello artistry of Yo-Yo Ma. Yo-Yo Ma’s cello adds a layer of sophisticated texture and emotional depth rarely heard in covers of this rock classic, while India.Arie’s vocals bring a fresh, soulful perspective. Santana’s guitar solo is, in itself, exceptional, imbued with his signature Latin-infused style and passionate phrasing, almost reaching the iconic status of Prince’s solo. This version’s masterful blend of diverse musical elements, coupled with Santana’s distinctive guitar voice, secures its place as the ultimate rendition of “While My Guitar Gently Weeps,” even amidst formidable competition.
| Arrangement | Innovative and Eclectic |
|---|---|
| Originality | Highly Original Interpretation |
| Solo | Santana’s Signature Latin-Rock Solo |
| Vocals | Soulful Vocals by India.Arie |
Alt text: Album cover for Carlos Santana’s “Guitar Heaven: The Greatest Guitar Classics of All Time,” featuring Santana, India.Arie, and Yo-Yo Ma’s collaboration on “While My Guitar Gently Weeps.”
Listen on Apple Music and Spotify.
