François Truffaut famously described Johnny Guitar as “the Beauty and the Beast of westerns, a western dream.” However, a closer look suggests it’s even deeper, resonating more like Orpheus: still dreamlike, but fundamentally a myth rather than a simple fairy tale. Think of Orpheus, the legendary Greek musician who dared to descend into the underworld to rescue his wife Eurydice, armed only with his lyre and enchanting melodies. He was promised her return on one condition: he must not look back at her (a condition tragically broken). Similarly, in an early, pivotal scene of Johnny Guitar, the eponymous musician, Johnny Guitar (Sterling Hayden), diffuses a tense standoff between Vienna (Joan Crawford) and a hostile posse with nothing but his guitar and a mesmerizing tune, an almost Orphic intervention. The subtle, yet profound twist in Johnny Guitar lies in the danger of looking: in this world, desire itself is destructive. Every glance carries the potential for annihilation. Hades himself was never so relentlessly cruel.
It’s a well-established point that despite the film’s title, Johnny Guitar isn’t the central protagonist. That distinction belongs to Vienna, portrayed by Joan Crawford, a sharp-witted businesswoman and occasional gunfighter. Vienna’s recently built saloon is strategically positioned to become incredibly valuable with the anticipated arrival of the railroad. However, the narrative’s driving force, the character who ignites the core conflict, is Emma, a local rancher consumed by jealousy and resentment, played with chilling intensity by Mercedes McCambridge. Emma vehemently opposes Vienna’s shrewd foresight and ambition.
Mercedes McCambridge’s portrayal of Emma is iconic. Rarely has such raw fear and self-hatred been so vividly captured on screen. Emma’s contempt is palpable, a burning, visceral emotion barely contained within her gaze. The film’s enduring power is encapsulated in the image of Emma, trembling with a mix of confusion and animosity, her fear twisting her words into harsh commands. Her seemingly fragile figure dominates every scene she inhabits. Emma stands out as one of cinema’s most terrifying villains precisely because she isn’t inherently evil. Instead, she is overwhelmed by relatable human flaws: confusion, insecurity, and a fear of both the “other” and her own desires. This internal turmoil manifests as uncontrolled, venomous hate.
Johnny Guitar is rich with subtext, inviting multiple interpretations. We can explore themes of sexual repression, evident in Emma’s self-loathing for her attraction to the outlaw Dancin’ Kid – an attraction she projects onto Vienna, fueled by jealousy and suspicion. There’s a Freudian layer too, with westerns, and particularly guns, functioning as potent phallic symbols. More intriguingly, a Lacanian reading emerges, where the promised but not-yet-built “railroad” and the associated wealth become Vienna’s – and perhaps the film’s – objet petit a, that elusive, ultimately unattainable object of desire. And of course, feminist interpretations abound, often positioning Vienna as a proto-feminist archetype. Yet, the “strong female protagonist subverting gender roles” analysis, while present, sometimes feels too simplistic, missing deeper, more nuanced subtexts.
Perhaps the most resonant and historically significant interpretation of Johnny Guitar positions it as a powerful critique of McCarthyism and the Hollywood blacklist. While the McCarthy era may have lost some of its immediate cultural relevance, its shadow still lingers. Films like Chaplin’s A King in New York, initially dismissed, now stand as potent indictments of political persecution. It’s crucial to remember the oppressive climate of the time; taking any stance against the blacklist risked professional exile. To embed a clear anti-blacklist message within a Hollywood film, even subtly, was an act of considerable political bravery, practically career suicide. Even Chaplin, notably, could only overtly condemn McCarthyism from the safety of exile.
It is now widely known that Philip Yordan, the credited screenwriter of Johnny Guitar, served as a front for Ben Maddow, who was blacklisted and unable to work openly in Hollywood. This context infuses the film with a palpable sense of righteous anger. The narrative itself mirrors the blacklist’s exclusionary logic: a mob of townsfolk, clad in black, demands the banishment and eventual execution of innocent individuals based on baseless accusations – a clear witch hunt driven by irrational fear. This allegorical layer alone would have been a daring and risky statement. However, Johnny Guitar‘s most potent scene goes further. Emma’s posse, dressed in funereal black, arrives at Vienna’s saloon, their ultimatum expired. They demand she reveal the location of the Dancin’ Kid, whom they intend to lynch for robbery. Vienna, in a stark white gown, plays piano, calmly defying their demands, exposing their senselessness.
Suddenly, a boot emerges from under a table. Vienna has been sheltering Turkey, the youngest member of the Kid’s gang, injured in a fall. Emma’s men seize Turkey, threatening to hang him immediately unless he confesses and implicates Vienna. Turkey, terrified, cries out to Vienna, “What do I do? I don’t wanna die!” The brilliance of this scene lies not just in its nuanced condemnation of the accusers and its empathy for those pressured into betrayal – Turkey’s plight evokes genuine compassion. Instead, it’s the raw, visceral portrayal of entrapment that is truly compelling. The scene humanizes the abstract political drama of McCarthyism, transforming it into something almost surreal, a nightmare of societal pressure and individual desperation.
This surreal quality is central to Johnny Guitar‘s enduring appeal. Its vibrant Trucolor palette and heightened melodrama lend themselves perfectly to postmodern re-evaluation. Its rich surfaces are endlessly mined for meaning. Johnny Guitar defies simple categorization, existing as camp spectacle, revisionist western epic, and political allegory simultaneously. Each interpretation feels valid. Did director Nicholas Ray intentionally aim to subvert genre conventions, to dismantle the very foundations of the quintessential American genre? The mythology of the Western, after all, holds a more profound place in American ideology than any Greek myth. Perhaps confronting this mythology and forging something new, something genuinely challenging, is the most profoundly American achievement. Johnny Guitar is not just “a western dream”; it’s an exploration of the American dream itself, with all its contradictions and dark undercurrents.
Score:
Cast: Joan Crawford, Sterling Hayden, Mercedes McCambridge, Scott Brady, Ward Bond, Ernest Borgnine, John Carradine
Director: Nicholas Ray
Screenwriter: Philip Yordan
Distributor: Paramount Pictures
Running Time: 110 min
Rating: NR
Year: 1954
Buy: Video
If you can, please consider supporting Slant Magazine. Since 2001, they’ve delivered uncompromising perspectives on film, music, television, and more. Independent publications like Slant are facing challenges, and your support keeps their content accessible and free.
If you appreciate their work, consider subscribing to their Patreon or making a donation.
